6 April
Today I awoke at 8:30am and meditated until 9, which provided me with the perspective and composure to venture out of my room into the village. The men are having a "function" (religious event) to rebuild the the small temple of Kharongcha. Twenty of them are gathered around the site, and began sawing and hammering shortly after dawn. Eight of them followed me with their eyes as I walked down the steps from my room, past their carpentry area, and along the village path to wash in the river.
I have never been as cold in my life as I was this morning, bathing in the river. My skull felt frozen solid, like an amplified ice-cream-headache. I felt victorious at the end, but in a sad way. Clean, but again, uncomfortable, and alone in my cold cleanliness. After six days of oily hair from the field (we returned from the field yesterday), I was desperate for a sense of freshness. That said, it is truly astounding how well the body can manage amidst dirt and grime. However, there is a limit; my face is brilliantly red from the combination of fire smoke, burning sun and bitter cold. Bimla asked me about it by pointing and laughing; the villagers have a different set of manners than we Westerners.
As I washed my clothes in a bucket today, 10 villagers (men and children) watched me, transfixed. I sit in the center of the village near the water tap, my arms deep in the water as I scrub and rub my clothes methodically to loosen the dirt. I use biodegradable soap but, as when I bathe, I feel terribly guilty about the soap, which ultimately runs into the river nearby. Sometimes the villagers come close, standing over me to get a better look. I am probably the biggest form of entertainment that they've had in a long time, so I understand their interest, but it makes me extremely self-conscious. There is little I can do except accept their stares, as anger would be an inappropriate response to their general kindness. After I washed, I drape my clothes around the house for the breeze to dry. But today it is so cold outside that my clothes are still dripping wet.
While my actions seem to captivate the villagers, their manners greatly amuse me. They pick their noses, burp, fart and shoot snot (truly a skilled feat) freely in public. They do not hesitate to point out something unusual, such as a rash that I have developed on my hands, or my bright red face. If Pritham wants something, he says, "Give me mobile," or "Give me money", which may also be a result of his limited English. There is no respect for privacy or space; strangers wander freely into my room without knocking, even when the door is closed tightly. Bimla often enters my room, plops down on the floor, and points to my belongings with questions. She once pointed at my retainer and when I showed her, said, "Like old man teeth!". And I breathe deeply and smile, speechless at the absurdity of my situation.
Wednesday, June 4
Washing
Language Differences
12 May
Besides Pritham, Bimla is the only other person with which I can speak English in Kharongcha. She is his sister-in-law, a 21 year old with two children. She learned in school and is one of the few villagers to have graduated from all 12 grades.
Bimla and her 1 year old daughter with me on the steps of Pritham's old home.
Our conversations are always scattered and broken, limited by her vocabulary in English and mine in Hindi. They usually begin with a focus on the fields; Bimla often says "I am grass, field", meaning she is soon going to work in the fields, pulling grass for the cows. She also usually looks at her hands and says, "My hands crack dirt from grass" and looks apologetically at the dark earth that is permanently implanted in the grooves of her large palms. "Oh, mmm..." I reply, as I look at my own hands, shinning white and clean in the sunlight. In those moments I feel my place as a temporary visitor more than ever, and it's all I can do not to push my hands into my pockets out of embarrassment.
Last time we chatted, we began to touch deeper topics, despite our language restrictions. We met in the field, I heading out of the village with my binoculars and bird book to watch the evening bird forage, and she with a basket on her back as she walked to pick grass for the cow's dinner. She commented on how hard she works and asked, as they often do, whether I cook and clean for myself in America. I told her that I do, and that I work hard in the park, so that my stays in Kharongcha are rest days. To her, who has probably worked every day of her life, my explanation must have sounded like a pathetic excuse for my inactivity. This may have led to her final remarks: "Here, Kharongcha, you fat...fingers fat. You go, come back, then thin." What??? I have not a clue what she was trying to say. Cultural and vocabulary differences create many such conversations.
Panni (Water)
A natural waterfall at our campsite in Chorduar.
The local people in these villages drink water straight from the river. It is a stunning sight to see them cup their hands into the river, a stream, or a direct faucet, and life the "water of India" (as they often call it) to their lips. A beautiful sight, pure and refreshing, and one that I envy.
Water has been a theme throughout my trip to India. From the moment I landed in the country, a constant alarm has sounded in the back of my mind: Is that water safe? Here in Kharongcha and in the park, water presents a unique set of challenges - social stigmas. Here, water is plentiful, since the Tirthan River is fed by copious streams, including those that run through our camp sites and beside Kharongcha. Although it is likely that the water is free of harmful bacteria, I filter all of my water unless it is boiled. The risks are too great for my peace of mind, especially with livestock and wild goat roaming alongside the rivers. Diarrheah and vomit in the forest just doesn't sound appealing.
So I filter it myself with my hand pump filter. The mechanism is pretty cool to see for the first time. And so people watch, fascinated, as I pump my water through a tube into my bright orange water bottle. The most awkward moment comes when new porters or a waiter in Gushani offer me a glass of water with a meal. I quietly accept the glass, but Pritham tsks and says matter-of-factly to the man, "Panni...filter" The generous boy always looks bewildered and stares at me with my orange water bottle as if I am a martian, incapable of accepting the most basic form of sustenance.
I feel immensely jealous when the men casually dip the jug in the river and fill their steel cups with fresh, cool water. I must maintain a constant mindfulness not to swallow - in the bath, when brushing teeth, when washing my face. A reminder to take nothing for granted in our privileged land of America.
The Lesson of Compassion
22 April
Now, one month in, I feel attached to these villagers. I would say that I have made friends. Bimla called me Lalit's "auntie" (they call all women that name, but it still warms my heart). Given Lal smiles brightly when I say "namaste" to him, and his children no longer run from me. I have shown my family photographs to the grocery men in Gushani and they serve me tea whenever I visit. Dhani and Pritham and I sometimes joke and laugh freely in camp.
Pritham and I walking a trail in the morning.
I realize why it is so important to understand, live and incorporate the human dimensions of conservation. When I first arrived, I disapproved of the villager's mushroom collection inside the park, although I sympathized with their motivation to collect it. Only now do I fully grasp their dependency on the vegetable and the difference that it can make in their family's survival for the year. Collecting several kilograms can transform a man from poor to rich, since they receive Rs. 10,000 per kg for the mushroom but often make only Rs. 2,000 per month at their full time jobs.
Dhani (left) and Pritham (right) admiring Pritham's brother's mushrooms after a day of collecting in the park.
How can I tell these people that they should not collect gucchii (mushroom)? Every trip into the forest yields income; it's as if they are harvesting rupees from the ground. When they show me their baskets brimming with mushroom, they instantly attach a price value to it. This morning, Pritham collected one gucchii and said, "Ten rupees! I have earned breakfast!"
Living in Kharongcha has opened my eyes to the role of gucchii in the villager's lives. Completely cutting off their source of income is harsh and irresponsible, and has obviously not worked (hundreds of trips are made into the park by villagers, even though the park's borders are legally closed to them), despite the good intentions to boost conservation by the park.
Conservation aside, the villagers' livelihoods are based on a fragile web of factors that are rapidly causing a decline in gucchii. Climate change appears to be decreasing the harvest of mushroom. Over-harvesting may turn the yield into an unsustainable one if people harvest the roots of the mushroom instead of the portion above-ground. And if the park decides to more stringently enforce its closure to people reaping the land, a more immediate shift of livelihood will be necessary.
In essence, gucchii collection will not be feasible for much longer. The villagers desperately needs to find other sources of income. Yet Pritham tells me that jobs are competitive and hard to find, especially since there is no vehicle road to the interior villages, such as Kharongcha. Agriculture is also a challenge because the villagers must carry out by foot all their crops.
The Forest Department is also inconsistent in its message of conservation. The Forest Guards do not seem to patrol the park. Pritham told me that hunters often come at night to easily avoid the Guards at the gate. Forest Guards also accept bribes: some meat in exchange for silence. A Forest Guard once met Pritham with his goats, walking on the road towards the park, and told him that he could not take his animals into the park to graze. Pritham feels this is unfair; in his words, "My goats eat only grass...", whereas hunters directly impact animal populations. Many of the locals feel that the Forest Guards should spend their time patrolling and catching hunters rather than sitting in the town range office or pestering shepards.
My trip has turned into more than a mere quest to publish an article in a peer-reviewed science journal. This is turning into a soul-renching journey to appease the people and their pheasants both in a sustainable way. How can we solve this problem? What recommendations can I make from my experience and the data that I am gathering? What will replace gucchii once it fades? I feel unqualified to write an article on this subject; I have many questions and few answers.
Kharongcha and the Villagers
27 March (journal entry)
Quiet, besides the songbirds, crows and river flowing beneath the village. The men cough with raspy, chest-deep muscles and spit frequently. Their clothes are earth-colored and dirty, ragged from age. The dark fabrics contrast starkly against the colorful garb of the Indian city-dwellers, perhaps because of their active lives in the field and the hassle of washing clothes in the villages.
Most people have sturdy hiking shoes and alternate with plastic sandles. Dirt is caked under their short fingernails, hands worn and scarred from years handling grass and wood. Women wear brightly colored headscarves to cover their hair, which trails in long braids down their backs. Loose salawar kamizes of browns and blues. Bright golden jewelry adorn their noses and ears and occasionally their fingers. Gray woolen vests are popular by both genders, and the men wear woolen hats, lined with bright colors in traditional patterns.
A resident of Kharongcha with the traditional "Kullu hat" worn by the men.
The women of Kharongcha.
Most people are friendly and curious, starring at me but smiling or replying a quiet "namaste" after I initiate. Children are shy and run away or turn their eyes when I meet their stare.
There is a timelessness here. The villagers and my assistants don't wear watches, so they ouldn't meet a time if I told them. Yet Pritham humors me: "Breakfast at 9?" he says every night before we depart. The men constantly ask me the time and always looked surprised, no matter if it is early or late. Why should time matter when your life is controlled by the sun? Rules of logic only apply if others follow.
I struggle to find my place here in the village. I have no set tasks; I am an outsider with few connections. Free to wander, I feel lost. I also feel very guilty when Pritham and Dhani prepare meals for me. My liberal, equality-above-all values ring out against the hierarchy that is so apparent throughout India.
18 April
Before I left Dehradun for GHNP, many of my friends told me that the "hill people" of Kullu District are lazy alcoholics. Their reputation among urban Indians is very poor. Yet I have observed a greater work ethic among the villagers than among even the busiest professors at the Wildlife Institute of India. Motivated by the drive to survive, the locals wake by 5am and work well past sunset, taking short breaks only for small meals, chai and occasionally a quick smoke from their hookas to warm their bodies from the bitter cold.
The men build houses, dig in the fields to plant potato and grain, blast apart rocks to build their homes, and supervise sheep and goats in the pastures. The women are incessantly washing, ringing, hanging, cooking, feeding, nursing, cleaning, milking, and picking grass for livestock in the fields. The young children are left to tend to themselves, so busy are their parents. Only in the evenings do people sit on rocks at discuss the day as they watch their children play cricket along the village path. Laziness comes with security and authority, yet in the villages I rarely see stillness; there is an untiring, unquestioned rhythm of movement and bustle.
Bimla, Tat and Sita with Bimla's two children, Sunyean and Lalit.
Seeing Beyond Pheasants
My time in the forest impacted me in a deep, life-changing way that a blog with short stories and photographs will never be able to fully capture. This frustrates me, but I will do my best to express the lessons I learned. This post contains a brief summary of my overall experiences. The following posts are excerpts from my journal and photographs to tell the story more vividly. Enjoy, and please give me comments on what you find most captivating.
Three days ago I returned to the land of hot water, toilets and advanced technology. As the car carried my exhausted, dirty and sunburned body through the winding hills and descended into the valley of Dehradun, I felt a mixture of relief and shock that this trying experience is finally over.
The past two months have been one of the most challenging times in my life. The fieldwork was much more physically demanding than I expected; somehow when I agreed to the project, I didn’t fully register that I would be working in THE Himalayas, the steepest mountain range in the world. For each of our eight trips into the park, we accessed the study sites by initially hiking narrow switchbacks that ascended to elevations of between 3,200 and 6,500 feet (1,000 to 2,000m) in 2 hours. I slipped and fell constantly over the rocky terrain, while my assistant Pritham, a local 34-year old man who has lived on these trails his whole life, walked daintily and steadily behind me, making me feel clumsy and inadequate.
My fieldwork team consisted of myself, Pritham and two porters who helped us carry our bags, cooked and attended the morning call counts with us (for additional protection against night time predators, such as bears and leopards). Dhani Ram, a 42-year old Forest Department assistant, worked as our porter for the full two months, whereas we hired a new man to be our second porter for each trip. The men were very courteous and hardworking but needless to say, I have not encountered many women over the past two months.
Pritham and Dhani setting up my tent at Shilt, one of our camp sites.
Our typical daily schedule was as follows: rise at 4am and walk 30 minutes in the dark to a call count station, then sit until 5:45am in the cold and listen for bird calls. Return to camp and eat breakfast (warm cereal - dahlia or halawa - or potato pancake – aloo parantha), then leave at 7am to hike a trail and count birds along the way. Since the birds are most active in the morning, fieldwork finished by 10:30am, leaving the entire day to hike the surrounding area, read, write, paint, take photographs, and count down the hours until sunset. For lunch we ate lentil soup (daal) and rice (chawal) every day. Dinner consisted of mixed vegetables and bread (chipati), which I learned to make myself. I headed to bed in my personal tent around 8:30pm and slept restlessly, waking every few hours to check the weather and time.
Learning to make chipotis with Dhani. He adds water to flour and forms the chipotis by throwing them from hand to hand, a skill that I have yet to master.
The mountains were stunning. Snow-capped and stark against the blue sky, they formed a landscape that never failed to impress me. Ominous dark clouds often serenaded us for hours with booming thunder, followed by frequent rain and hail. Although beautiful, the rain and cold temperature seeped into my clothing, my bones and my spirit. The long hours in the afternoon were primarily spent in solitude, since my porters could speak little English and Pritham (who knew decent English) was shy and preferred to speak Hindi with the other men.
The view from Koilipoi, a camp site that we shared with many brown bears and leopards.
After 4-6 days in the park, we returned home to to rest in Kharongcha, Pritham’s village which I used as my base camp for the 2 months. Only 15 minutes walk outside the park, Kharongcha is a quaint village composed of 3 families, 7 houses, 30 people and 2 English speakers (Pritham and his sister-in law, Bimla). My accommodations were lovely; I stayed in Pritham’s new house that is still under construction, yet he managed to finish building one room for me and furnished it with furniture he built himself. His family lived in another house, so I lived alone. Pritham cooked all meals for me in a make-shift kitchen in one of the unfinished rooms on the bottom floor.
A view of Kharongcha from the trail leading into the village. In front center is Pritham's new home, where I stayed in a room on the second floor.
My room.
Since Kharongcha is extremely remote, none of the homes have toilets or warm running water. One central tap with cold river water serves the entire village. Electricity is inconsistent; the wires were broken for the first 3 weeks of my stay, so we cooked and ate by candlelight in the evenings. I bathed and answered “nature’s call” (as they call it in India) near the river, which just so happens to be fresh, pure, glacial runoff. My first few baths were so cold that I had to force myself to breathe, after which I focused on washing only the important parts. This made my infrequent trips into town (occasionally we stayed at Sai Ropa, the Forest Department range office where they have bathrooms, when we traveled to Banjar) all the more momentous.
My bathroom in Kharongcha.
Kharongcha is inaccessible by road, so we walked 1 hour on a mountain trail to reach Gushani, the nearest town, where we would buy wilted vegetables and packaged food each week. Occasionally we would travel to Banjar, which was an additional 30 minutes away by bus, to purchase non-moldy vegetables, English newspapers, and sweets. We carried all our purchases back with us to Kharongcha, a trip that usually took 2 hours since it was mostly uphill.
The grocery store in Gushani where we purchased most of our food. The owners were very sweet brothers who often gave me tea as I sat on the bench to the front left of the store.
Pritham buying vegetables from a stall in Banjar.
My greatest challenges were both physical and mental. The steep terrain, early mornings and poor weather. My inability to communicate with the people around me. The isolation and challenge of reaching mainstream society. The shortage of stimuli in the peaceful village, which came as a shock to my urban-raised mind. The lack of bathroom facilities and awkwardness I felt whenever I walked past the villagers to “my part” of the river. The culture shock I felt as I attempted to live among a culture that I could not interact with, only observe.
Living in Kharongcha gave me a unique experience to see first-hand how “local people” utilize the natural resources around them. As a scientist, this view is very important, because I no longer think of the villagers as naïve, impersonal individuals. They are vibrant and hardworking communities that happen to live in a valley so remote that they are forced to rely on agriculture and wild mushrooms for their livelihood. They are also my friends.
Pritham's wife, Sita, with some of the children and kids of Kharongcha.
This trip truly has helped me move beyond the pheasants. I am now able to clearly see the broader picture on an intimate level and understand more of the complications behind conservation and local communities.
Previous Posts
- Nov 27 (1)
- Oct 31 (1)
- Oct 18 (1)
- Oct 04 (1)
- Sep 24 (1)
- Sep 19 (1)
- Sep 06 (1)
- Sep 03 (1)
- Aug 31 (1)
- Jul 28 (1)
- Jul 15 (1)
- Jul 08 (1)
- Jun 26 (1)
- Jun 13 (1)
- Jun 04 (8)
- Jun 01 (1)
- May 05 (1)
- Mar 24 (1)
- Mar 23 (2)
- Mar 13 (5)
- Mar 09 (1)
- Mar 03 (2)
- Feb 29 (1)
- Feb 28 (1)
- Feb 26 (1)
- Feb 25 (1)
- Feb 24 (1)
- Feb 22 (2)
- Feb 17 (1)
- Jan 17 (1)